Tue 20 May 2008
Engaging the Christian Psuedo-Intellectual
Posted by Fiacharrey under Pagan Community, Paganism, Self Improvement, Philosophy
Comments Off
I discuss having to deal with Christian psuedo-intellectual apologists in my previous article, but those people who accost us are often not technically apologists. Apologetics are about defending one’s position. They are about attacking yours. A popular apologetics website, CARM, advises their would-be missionaries into the dark realms of Neo-Paganism to stick to asking questions:
I find that asking questions is one of the best things you can do when talking to anybody in any different theological system. I ask questions and listened intently to the answers and then ask more questions. Invariably I begin to discover inconsistencies in their answers and I politely ask more questions around those inconsistencies. It does not take long for the person to start seeing that their belief system has serious problems. Remember, anything that is not based upon the Christian faith is false and will have errors which you can discover through asking questions.
I like the CARM site. It’s probably one of the best Christian apologetics sites out there, actually. I think it’s worth the effort to examine what they have and, once you realize that’s probably the best there is, it’s pretty easy to be well prepared for any comers.
All of the information they have about Neo-Paganism is under the heading of “Wicca.” They don’t really distinguish between types of Neo-Paganism. I think Wiccans account for about 80% of Neo-Paganism anyway, so it’s probably safe for them to keep it simple. Just keep in mind that to them, Neo-Pagan and Wiccan are the same thing, so all this information applies to their approach to any Neo-Pagan.
So, the CARM method is to start off questioning you to put you on the defensive. The missionary is not there to defend Christianity, at least not at first. He’s there to attack your beliefs though what are basically softened up court-room cross examination techniques. In other words, they are forcing you to be the apologist. CARM provides a convenient list of questions to get the missionary started:
1. Do the gods and goddesses of Wicca actually exist?
2. If they actually exist, how do you know they exist?
3. If your tradition contradicts the tradition of another Wiccan, can they both be objectively true?
4. How do you feel about believing in the religious system where you cater your religion to your desires?
5. if you cater/construct your religion according to our desires, then isn’t it nothing more than your own invention?
6. Is Wicca able to be shown to be false or is it all non-verifiable ideas?
7. If your spells and incantations produce results, how do you know that the power behind the results is good or not?
8. How do you know that there is something more sinister behind Wicca?
9. Why do you think that rituals dealing with candles, knives, and such are able to affect nature?
Yes, this approach is somewhat obnoxious and, as I suggested before, somewhat intellectually dishonest. But it can be used to our personal advantage. It would be worth while to consider these questions in your own spiritual practice and think about how you would answer these questions and similar ones in a polite and respectful manner. The primary benefit to you out of all this interaction with Christians is that the Christian acts as a sounding board for your own philosophical development. In other words, it will help your personal growth to allow them to be the interrogator they so badly seem to want to be. In a way, that’s exactly what the Christian is hoping for. They just make the additional assumption that, once shown you are in error, you should become Christian instead of just a slightly more sophisticated Pagan.
Here is how I might answer these questions if they were asked of me:
1. Do the gods and goddesses of Wicca [i.e. your Neo-Pagan Path] actually exist?
“Of course they do!”
2. If they actually exist, how do you know they exist?
“They told me.” Yes, I am being a little cheeky, but this line of questioning amuses me. They sound like Atheists here.
3. If your tradition contradicts the tradition of another Wiccan, can they both be objectively true?
“No. But so what? No religion is objectively true. They all deal with the subjective.” This answer is unfortunate in that it takes the focus off of you.. The Christian would have to jump from questioning you to Christian-Defense-Mode, which does you no good. Hopefully, they will have better sense than to ask this stupid question in the first place. Another answer might be: “None of the traditions hold an exclusive claim on Truth, so none of them objectively contradict each other as far as I know.” One problem with that is that you might end up defending religious paths you don’t even subscribe to. It might get complicated.
4. How do you feel about believing in the religious system where you cater your religion to your desires?
5. if you cater/construct your religion according to our desires, then isn’t it nothing more than your own invention?
I take these together, because they revolve around the same point. This brings up a lot of conflicting issues for me that I have not yet entirely resolved for myself. I think they actually have a good point here and one in which I often join them in making. I think there is a potential pitfall in Neo-Paganism in that, if you custom tailor your beliefs to exactly where you are now, spiritually, there is no real room for growth. You have nothing to give you direction on where to go next.
But, at least a partial response to the question they pose is this: “Everyone is on their own spiritual journey. We all follow the spiritual path of our own choosing. Some prefer taking a train, where everyone is along the same track. Some prefer going by car where the driving is up to you. Yes, you can get lost that way, and you might get sidetracked on occasion, but the trip is a lot more fulfilling.”
Another response, although seemingly in direct conflict to what I just said, is this: “We don’t construct our religion, we discover it. We don’t choose our gods. They choose us. Really nobody has a choice in what they believe. You can’t wake up one morning and chose to believe the Sun will rise in the West. You would have to be given a good reason to believe or stop believing, something. And then, when you have that good reason, you can’t help but to change your belief. So, it’s not something you can control.”
6. Is Wicca able to be shown to be false or is it all non-verifiable ideas?
This strange question is premised on this: that Christianity is falsifiable. You have a few choices here. One is that you can explain what would have to be demonstrated to you in order to abandon Wicca or whatever path you have chosen. I would do this if asked, I think, but my answer is long, complicated, and way too specific to me to go into here. Another option is to patiently explain that you follow a religion, not a science. Science is about falsifiable claims, not religion. Religion is about faith. Of course, that would lead to a confrontation about their bizarre belief that Christianity is falsifiable, putting them on the defensive. I’d avoid that if I could, because you don’t get any personal benefit out of their defending their beliefs.
7. If your spells and incantations produce results, how do you know that the power behind the results is good or not?
8. How do you know that there is something more sinister behind Wicca?
Again, these two questions are basically asking the same thing. My answer is: “Well, that’s where ‘faith’ comes into it, I suppose.” Of course, the question might easily be turned around: “How does a Christian know that the power they pray to is good or not?” All the bizarre demonic conspiracy theories they come up with to explain why all other world religions are false and “of the Devil” can just as easily be applied to theirs. They really don’t like that, though. Whenever I bring this up, the person I am “dialogueing” with blows a gasket. I’d avoid that argument unless you want to see them explode. Also, you lose the practical benefit of this interaction I’ve been talking about, though you do get the cruel satisfaction of watching them fluster.
9. Why do you think that rituals dealing with candles, knives, and such are able to affect nature?
“The same reason anyone else expects their prayers to be answered. It’s all part of having faith in a religion.” They might not understand that ritual is really a form of prayer. It’s “prayer with props.” That might take a little bit of explanation.
In spite of all this advice I give about appologetics, I don’t care for apologetics in general. While apologetics have their place, I suppose, they often turn logic on its head in a mockery of true philosophy. Where logic starts with a premise and progresses to a conclusion, apologetics start with a conclusion and builds up the arguments in reverse, often ignoring or concealing the premise altogether. When I defend my faith, I don’t think it’s really apologetics. I am not merely defending my own conclusions, I am exploring them and testing them along with my “attacker.” If my conclusions cannot withstand my scrutiny, with the assistance of a Christian sounding board, they must be revised or replaced.
If you are a Christian who is interested in saving my soul, I always welcome your questions. Try your best to poke holes in my philosophy. It’s what I live for. I have learned and grown a lot from those kinds of interactions, and mostly when an inconsistency or error has been shown to me. I love being shown I’m wrong more than just about anything. And this invitation is not just for Christians. Anyone who wants to show me the error of my ways is invited to join in.
petite nude pics
starwars xxx
beautiful naked asian woman
ass shakin
gay cock sucking mpegs
naked underage girls
secretaries caught fingering
anal latex
free incest sex movies
caught son wearing a dress
hand made olathe boots
amateur upskirts
video game porn
interracial gay wrestling
dog knot lovers
Blowjob Ninjas-2
shoe boot fetish
boob cum
Mom And The Pop CD-1
dog booties
upskirts crossed legs
tranny anal dildo
bridal shower themes
female nude bodybuilder
dad caught with nieghbors teen daughter
live sexcams
zana ffm
my first pelvic examination
cleveland ohio zoo
gang bang facials
teen boy love
licking cum filled asses
pantyhose wrestling
high school boys
celebrity uncensored
ladyboy cock
small dogs for adoption
gag on my dick
faded glory footwear
ebony lesbian porn
anal whore
diflucan infection vaginal yeast
nude female videos
Mommy Loves Em Young CD-1
xxx home made videos
Latin Anal Whorefest-2
adult toys toy discount store
femdom movies
deep throat video clips
avril lavigne blowjob
nude female videos
live sexcam vinden
rich girl
mom suck
shaved teen
canadian small business loan
Dirty 30s-2 CD-1
big dick tight pussy
clitoris pierced
exotic sex
My Friends Hot Mom-10 CD-2
latex mummification duct tape bondage
preteen suck
big brothers charleys lesbian lover
latina trannys
natural remedy for ingrown facial hair
bondage sites
Booty Annihilators-2 CD-1
crossdressing chat
drunk fuck party
pregnant bitch
www. old cunt and young cock .com
nervous voyeur thumbs
big tit latina
DP Milfs CD-2
the simpsons sex
teen wet pussy
big mens swimwear bikini
male bondage stories
silk cut cigarette online retailer
jesse hentai
fat nude sexy women
stop smoking hypnosis
cunt fuck ass shit jizz
free bbw pussy
spanking videos male punishment spanking
blog petra verkaik
post office saloon & grill redding ca
sexcam amateurs
cartoon sex galleries
jetsons nude
bondage sex videos
small asses
latex allergy foods
tranny couples
horny neighbor wife
shaved orientals
squirting snatch
gay black men fucking
varvara galitsin blog
child incest kiddy porn
girl wear a thong
girls in thongs in high school
naturist young girl
DP Milfs CD-2
best free porn
lg vx4500
big ass porn
big tits blowjobs
young orchids
boys first porn
free wet dripping cunts
petite fitness models pics
deep color hdmi
bukkake extreme
hand job clips
stick your tongue in slave
young teen sex free
college dorm checklist
twink in bed
big black whores
maid anal
free twink nudes boys
chubby lesbians cotton
euro shemale
free sexcams no e-mail
hentai cheerleaders
beaver shave
shemale orgy
exploited indian teens
women sucking dick
indian head saskatchewan
free handjob thumbs
mexican stop smoking no prescription needed
bizarre toy insertions
orgasm female
gorgeous blonde
cigarette torture
topless maid costume
dog humping leg
hairstyles female celebrities
college cheerleader photos
twinks sample video
shaved testicles cocks
le pornographe
big ass teen
pornstar moviezone
do wealthy people join the military
Mom And The Pop CD-1
flight northwest airline brazil
spanking videos male punishment spanking
hot redhead galleries free
fucking in stockings
pussy on huge penis
free filipina nude
asian sexcam philippines
trackless shower doors
femdom secretary
the affect of learning style on student classroom behavior
free streaming retro porn
cartoon fingering
sucking own cock
asian panty
quitting smoking by hypnosis
transexual dating service
santa-fe secretaries desk
male masterbation guide
flexible ebony girls
peeing on little girls
xtra large grannies
erotic lesbian sex
free glory hole
amateur girlfriends and wives
pleasure mask with ball gag
black butt hole
office desk layout designs
masterbation machines for men
russian lesbians
students caught having sex in school increasing
ass to mouth merry go round
girl tight jeans
does getting your tongue pierced hurt
amateur uncensored closeup porn vids
alabama beach condo rentals
bi swingers in africa
adult chat operator
hot chick fucked hard
amateur chicks
ass brazil
free blow job video
keywords pill for penis enlargement
My Girlfriend Wants To Do Porn-2 CD-2
midget blowjobs
queens zoo
granny black sex
anal prolapse
tit torture toys
biodegradable adult diapers
sex party tricks
hunk underwear galleries
paris hilton sex video download
nude brunettes viewed from behind
petite girl strips
dad and daughter fuck
anal cum ffm
indian pichunter
soulja boy tell ‘em
free group sex pic
porno free movie clips
revolving grooming table dogs
swallow and squirt
midget blowjobs
teacher stress article
voyeur fucking
electric clit torture
lesbian orgasim
sexy mexicans
zac efron nude
cream pie panties
nylon shell lined hooded jacket
lesbian slave blog
gorgeous male models
mom daughter lesbian
old movies
fat women young stud
clitoris closeup
cute chubby pussy
girl scout swap kits
lesbians oral
best bestiality vids
older adult piercing women tgp
fucking wife
milf hunter susie
anime gangbang
speech for student council secretary
free vintage porn pics
racist korean jokes
kream squirting
nude brunettes viewed from behind
squirting females
women g string models
xxx proposal hardcore sex deal
wife needs a bare ass spanking
free galleries of twinks
secretary masturbation
small paparazzi
huge cocks in tight pussies
young boy smooth video free twink nude
cash strapped teens
adult podcast
squirting females
clit lickin
horny fat chicks
guys dick
1992 polaris trail boss
micheal vick chew toy
ebony incredible pass
hairy vagina in nylons
lesbians sucking nipples
hot teen thong
pussy on huge penis
women favorite sex toy
dirty shit
hot ebony girls
barnyard sexcom
hard female orgasm video
hustler club
ebony models in thongs
horny teen bitch drinks jizz
penis large
thong sex
tribal horse tattoos
paris hilton sex video download
gator metal stud punches
smash mouth waste
cigarette making machines
fuck me please
pussy and legs
tattoo ideas for girls
wet legs
male erotic art
sexy erotic models
porn queens
free adult stream video
preteen passwords
tight pussy close up
nude college chicks
free clit pumping pics
lg m5500c-ba
blonde teen gangbang
thick black girls
ipanema girls in thongs
penis enlargement images
nude nylon
avril paparazzi
male anal masturbation
men sex
banned paparazzi photos
sj wannabe korean
bdsm illustrated
reality king adults
gorgeous male models
gay men naked
leather granny boots
female masturbation blog
naked indian men
mom daughter lesbian
pics of thong contests
post office saloon & grill redding ca
shit lovers
lingerie showers for brides
sex party tricks
yj transmission swap
yourself tile shower bench
worlds longest penis
dog cunt
cum on her hairy pussy
hairy redhair pussy
petite tit
butt thong
free erotic pictures
nude asian men
big cock tranny
helen white slut interracial
suck off black men
hot sexy legs
bukkake sperm
yellow latex dress
horny college chicks
shaved brunette defloration
shyla stylez ffm
brianna banks in latex
crossed legs girls
mom boy sex
amateur girlfriends and wives
cheerleader crotch
petite lesbians oriental
adult massage + myrtle beach
ashley olsen naked
dog knot lovers
dog booties
period fetish
girl hogtied and machine fucked
bridal shower themes
male nude model
sole fetish
sexy grannies older women
girls with small breasts
preteen boys erect penis
pregnant teen photos
kaitlyn olsen
fuck whore
medical bondage nurses
flexible packaging material suppliers
drunk anal sex
femdom kink
bondage mature
gossip girl
shemale rimjob
old amateur
free korean gay videos
the free voyeurweb main page
fit college girls
bree olsen dildo
milf in thong
gang sex
twistys bree olsen movie samples
school girls xxx
male to female transsexual vaginal sex
little red riding hood
korean shemale
deep anal dildo
cfnm events in uk
extreme thong
shower orgies
femdom stories enemas
oriental teen fucking
backyard blowjob
interracial payperview porn
fetish sluts
little boys feet
milk my jizz
transvestite creampies
maria sharapova naked
big blow jobs
horse shoe tattoos
slut deep
japanese fetish
plaid school uniforms
model-eve nylon lesbian
creampie party
female bdsm
south korean tranny bars
insest cartoon
adult pass forum
walking the dog
camel toe indian
naked news videos
nude masturbation
free porn movie downloads
male strip show
sex noises
jessica simpson paparazzi
female orgasm sound clip
hot fat sex
average 14 year old male penis size
hot club de paris
masturbation lessons
transvestism and bondage
cum in my ass
nude twins
fucking red heads
nurse porn pics
preteen bikini sites
swatch paparazzi watch
jizz in her mouth
adult movie rentals
tiny teen monster cock
cartoon fingering
horny teen bitch drinks jizz
skinny puppy pics
pregnant cock
latex porn
amature wife swap sex video free
dirty doctor
medical office billing software
nude marykate and ashley olsen
hot toon sex
redhead porn movies
gothic make tip up
nude female tattooes
reality companies in hot springs arkansas
naked indian men
granny jizz
13 year old girls fingering vagina
nurse fucking mom
clitoris gallery closeups
throw some ds on that bitch
hairy men sex
squirting ass
nylon fetish tgp free
pine log furniture
gay free thumbnails
college football tv schedule
tumble extreme in ky
bound bondage
mouth throat
horny bbw
grannies fucked
cheerleader for girls in richmond
interracial sex short stories
saigon kick mp3
getting stretch marks legsi 15 female dont know tried
zana ffm
long skinny dick
small asses
lesbian wives
hardcore sylvia saint
school girls xxx
dirty pair hentai
teen boy love
www sexcam de
nude family beach
midget porn clips
pregnant mothers naked
engine swap kits
naked latino men
teen fat
the female orgasm
housewife amateur pantyhose
hustler lena
shemale sperm
full body shower
penile oral stimulation
indian womens tongue
young olsen twins
msn photo swap messenger
hard drive recovery
naked girlfriend
male rape
amateur homemade sex videos
black lesbians tongue kissing and licking pussies
pantyhose buy dvd
Buttman Belas ELoucas CD-2
little kids sex
latex body stocking
chubby twinks
indian whore
small block chevy head swap
hardcore strapon lesbian
Mom Got Ass CD-2
black moms id like to fuck
briana banks sucking
night shift nurses hentai
granny bukkake
Dirty Talk CD-1
Its Huge-9 CD-1
free girls peeing
massive squirting
barefoot redhead girls
sluts taking it hard
sylvia dorfman idaho
tongue pussie lesbians
ladyboy anal
free adult funny downloads
teen chat
vintage fishing reels
Fuck Me Strong-3 CD-2
latex allergy deaths
girl piercing her pussy
preteen incest toons
indian sex gallery
used office furniture miami
tiny clit
nude marykate and ashley olsen
monster cocks cum
pregnant squirting pussy juice
bondage oral
sexy asian women smokers
nude teen model
giant gold mens watches
secretaries caught fingering
lesbian video
sylvia hutson talent agency
mutual masturbation stories
paris hilton sex porn
lesbians orgasm
family sex pics
skinny non nude young
toy teen pussy
amateur girlfriends and wives
cartoon fingering
redhead fucks
Little April-4
2007 college football schedule
college dorm checklist
Mommy Loves Em Young CD-1
pantyhose wrestling
ntsc secam dk dvd/vcr player
tattoo design tribal celtic
saint sylvia mpeg
sweet young pussy
spank naughty student fuck
smash mouth michigan
huntington teacher walter lundahl pedophile boys
shaved brunette defloration
young girl porn
thong off
anal sex in pantyhose
lesbian latex
long and pointy nipples
drunk mommy
free zoo sites
spanking of teen girls
moms teaching teens how to have sex
black virgins
tight black virgin pussy
olsen twin nude
oriental facial cumshot
grandmas shaved
giant fat cock
student hentai
bdsm slaves in missouri
gay black fucking
sexy 3d toons
blonde swallow cum
black pornstars big boobs
index gallery asian teen
drunk dorm
office sex mpegs
rogue community college grants pass oregon
fda approved penis enlargement pills
free information on penis enlargement
hot anime hentai
young underwear models
horse shoe tattoos
pussy popping
pregnant panties
my squirting pussy
2004 holiday rambler admiral 36 foot
granny free fist
sister masturbated my penis
anatomy of the throat
life of paparazzi
vintage butts
Mademoiselle CD-2
nude incest
full porno mpgs
infinity symbol tattoo
lesbian porn stars strapon
download free jenna jameson porn videos file
schoolgirl free gallery
tattoos tribal art
asian sex mpegs
real rape video
pantyhose sissies
big tits oriental girls blowjob on sofa
drunk anal sex
cum nurse
avril nude
girl hand job
korean bathing suit sex avi
latex mummification
free femdom trailers
stocking glamour nostalgic glamour
hidden neighbors sex cam
proadult quantum password
stick your tongue in slave
topless indian
carnival cruise ship glory
paris hiltin nude
free streaming retro porn
naked women with tattoos
underwear twinks
world sexcom
trans anal
drunk mature orgy
swallow and squirt
dragonball porn
My Best Friend’s Mom Takes It Up The Ass CD-1
college girls naked
Mom And The Pop CD-1
erotic rape stories
midget blowjobs
tube porn
eskimo pornstars
marc jacobs nylon bag
penis human growth hormone
british whores
sexy horny moms
blonde pornstar fucked in ass
fisting mom
no download sex videos
squirting lesbian bukkake
asian porn sites
petite cocktail dress
mature office lesbian
young video models
housewife amateur pantyhose
preteen wearing thongs
disney sex toon
young lady chatterly mpg
Big Dicks Little Asians-2 CD-1
adult web site reviews
slut galleries
lesbian fisting orgasm
first orgasm stories
hot club de paris
naked blond
big clit women sex
hustler club
asian sexcam philippines
mature women biker babes thong photos pierced menstrual
secretary sex video
mature orgys
the glory hole
xxx home made videos
monster cum loads
rape girls
teen halloween parties
humiliation spanking
gorgeous pantyhose
asian girls xxx
sleeping whore
amateur couple fucking
sex education for teens
amateur teen orgasm
deep anal dildo
naked brothers band
pregnant suck
herbal remedy stop smoking
asian girl galleries
big tit videos
handjob & cumshot
latex stockings plus size
naked preteen boys
cumming on tongue
clitoris pierced
cfnm handjobs blowjobs college
tango daily tongue cleaner
pinellas county schools
petite interacial
mom and dad sex
free mpegs of teens
website design seattle
penis enlargement before and after photos
paris cheap apartments
swingers movie
American Daydreams-5 CD-2
amateur strapon