Tue 6 Jun 2006
While the latest post on Right Wing of the Gods doesn’t outright say they are shutting down the blog, they strongly suggest it. “More of us will redirect our efforts elsewhere. See you later.” This saddens me deeply. Many times, I considered spreading the word about their site and just never got around to it. I never put it in my blogroll or told more than one or two folks about it. I considered writing a review about their blog, but never “got around to it.” I just took for granted that they would be around a long time. Truth be told, my “liberal bias” assuredly played a role.
It’s not a big secret that I am not, nor ever have been, a conservative. I used to be as radically liberal as they come. Surprisingly, though, my exploration of paganism has actually tempered my political views — pushed me towards the right, so that now I am only moderately liberal. I think what paganism really did for me was help me break free of the whole liberal/conservative dichotomy altogether and think outside that simple paradigm. In some ways that made me more conservative. In others it made me… something all together different. But enough about me.
While I don’t always agree with RWOTG, their arguments tend to be well reasoned. While they are conservative, they obviously don’t just mindlessly pull the “party line.” They offer a third point of view in what often gets simplified into a two sided debate. For example, in an article about Iraq, the writer gives a well reasoned argument for an option that hasn’t been really discussed: allowing Iraq to become several separate sovereign countries. My opinion is that theirs is a reasonable conservative solution that will not be considered by the current administration for a pretty simple reason: it would make it too hard to get the oil.
In another article about “children gulags,” I couldn’t agree with them more. (Except that I do insist on my son saying “sir” and ma’am” to me and to all adults.) That is one issue I fall on the “conservative” side about. I think our permissive attitudes about raising children, all the fluffy feel-good self-esteem crap, has done immense harm.
Unfortunately, I visited their site too infrequently to notice the decline in regular posting. They went from about a post every day back in December, to about one every other day or so in February, to a sharp decline in March, during which they had a shake-up in writers. After that, the site was updated once, maybe twice a month. I know how hard it is to keep blogging when it feels like nobody is reading and nobody cares, but I sincerely hope they decide to stick it out and keep up their work.
Whether you are on the “right” or the “left”, RWOTG gives a pagan some meat to chew over. They are a worthy opponent in the “clash of ideas” — one that just might win a few and cause us to reconsider some of our cherished but less rigorously examined ideas. This is my pledge to the folks at Right Wing of the Gods: if you keep writing, I’ll do my part to spread the word about you, and I will blogroll you guys. You represent a minority voice in the pagan community, and one that needs to be heard and considered.
3 Responses to “ Right Wing of the Gods Closing Down? ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from Cypress Nemeton » Blog Archive » Paganism and Values
June 23rd, 2006 at 8:26 am[…] Antistoicus recently responded to an article I wrote about the blog he founded and my sorrow at seeing it seem to die out. He and I share a basic philosophy that seems to be sadly neglected in modern paganism: that of the existence of a universal morality, or sense of “values.” Even people who read and enjoy his writing largely don’t seem to understand what lies at its core: … [L]ook at the guestbook for the Almond Jar… Count the number of people who post things like “wonderful site, greatly agree”, but under “morality, subjective or objective” answer “subjective”. Most of the site consists of an attempt to construct an objective theory of morality, in which most of the theology is partially rooted. More often than not, the fan club didn’t even read what they were praising. […]
-
Pingback from Cypress Nemeton » Blog Archive » Two Blogs Added: Rite Wing TechnoPagan and Pagan Vigil
July 2nd, 2006 at 8:42 pm[…] A little while back, I grieved the loss of a voice of Pagan divergent opinion I found in Right Wing of the Gods. I searched for a while for something to replace it in my irregular blog reading and gave up. Then completely out of the blue, I discovered two blogs that fit the bill. […]
June 22nd, 2006 at 2:05 am
Hi. I’m the one who wrote the post that Fiacharrey is mentioning. I thank him for his kind words, but would like to clarify.
The contributors to RWOTG post fairly independently of each other, so I can only speculate about what the others will do. As for myself, I must have sounded more discouraged than I was feeling as I wrote that piece.
Not that I’m not feeling discouraged in some ways. One need only look at the guestbook for the Almond Jar to see one of the reasons why, strongly hinted at. Count the number of people who post things like “wonderful site, greatly agree”, but under “morality, subjective or objective” answer “subjective”. Most of the site consists of an attempt to construct an objective theory of morality, in which most of the theology is partially rooted. More often than not, the fan club didn’t even read what they were praising.
Values were never a side issue as far as I was concerned, but among those I find myself meeting through Paganism, values seldom seem to be of interest. There are exceptions to this, of course, but relatively few, even among the Conservatives, who one might think would respond positively to the concept of “traditional Western values”.
Instead, on one such list which shall remain unnamed, I got to have the truly surreal experience of watching people on a supposedly religious list consider the merits of committing genocide. Treachery against one’s friends and allies who have risked so much, the mass murder of the innocent, the destruction of an entire civilization based on the transitory difficulties of the moment - all were considered with less gravity than I would expect to see out of my grandmother as she would decide what kind of bread to serve with dinner. These may be somebody’s traditional values, but they certainly aren’t mine.
Darned unsettling, and very typical of my online experience. If being this “Antistoicus” person were the largest part of my life, I probably would be profoundly depressed. But for all that is going wrong for this online persona that some people relate to me through, behind it there’s still this guy named “Joseph” in Chicago, and offline the world is getting friendlier for him. Not necessarily easier, but friendlier, and at some point one just looks and asks oneself “where would I rather spend time”.
The very role was always kind of a weird quirk. By profession, I’m an Applied Mathematician, not a Classicist, having found myself writing the Almond Jar in order to try to get a group going, not because I wanted to be in charge of a group, but because there were no Hellenic Pagan groups active in Chicago.
What I’m retreating to, then, is to spending more time doing the things I love most. My research, spending time with family and friends, my hobbies … and whether I’ve gotten anywhere in my efforts in Pagandom, with a clear conscience I can now turn to the gods and say that I did my best in their service, and I did it for a good, long time.
This is not really “goodbye”. I might very well post some more stuff, but there are so many other places I have to be right now, and really have for some time, where my efforts have proved so much more fruitful, that I don’t picture doing so very often. Maybe not even ever, I don’t know.
That’s what I was getting at when I said that some of us would find that we had other places to be. I appreciate the trackback offer and might just take you up on that, but I don’t see the low traffic numbers so much as being a crushing disappointment as I see them as being life’s way of telling me where my efforts will be more useful. Having the intro. to statistics class I was going to teach cancelled because only three students signed up was a source of discouragement, because it spoke to a lack of interest in the subject matter that made no sense. With the incredible multitude of blogs out there, many of them very good, this made sense and I can embrace that.
And the weather’s been really nice. Chicago even had a spring for once, and I was glad to be outside for most of that. It’s cool. I appreciate the support, but I’m doing fine, and God willing, so are Dan and the others.